Thursday, January 3, 2008

Open Love Letter to Hendrik Hertzberg

Why did I let my New Yorker subscription lapse? Reading the online version makes me feel like a poor person. Eew. Anyway, Here’s Hendrik Hertzberg on Romney vs. Huckabee:
[Romney] went on to patronize rival religions, administering quick head pats to Catholicism (“I love the profound ceremony of the Catholic Mass”), evangelicalism (for the “approachability” of its version of God), Pentecostalism (“tenderness of spirit”), Lutheranism (“confident independence”), Judaism (“ancient traditions”), and Islam (“frequent prayer”—a bit feeble, that).

Missing from this litany, of course, was something to the effect of “I appreciate the deep commitment to reason of the agnostics and atheists.” Indeed, the only “religion” that Romney had anything rude to say about was “the religion of secularism.” He pointed scornfully at the “empty” cathedrals of Europe as evidence of “societies just too busy or too ‘enlightened’ to venture inside and kneel in prayer,” adding a little later that “any person who has knelt in prayer to the Almighty” has “a friend and ally in me.” Take that, NATO. On your knees.

Secularism is not a religion. And it is not true that “freedom requires religion just as religion requires freedom,” as Romney maintained. What freedom, including religious freedom, requires is, precisely, secularism—which is to say, state neutrality in matters of religion. (Nor does religion require freedom, as the European past and the Middle Eastern present demonstrate; religions, plural, do, however.)

Amen, sister. Hendrik Hertzberg for president. Also, if you imagined him looking all roly-poly and lederhosened, you were wrong (and shame on you, racist). The man is dashing.

2 comments:

Lesley said...

i'd vote for a hottie like that!

Lizzie said...
This comment has been removed by the author.